Everyone on this Train is a Suspect by Benjamin Stevenson
Genre: Mystery, Humour
Read: 25th November 2024
Published: 17th October 2023
★★★★★ 5 stars (and another 5!)
DESCRIPTION:
6 WRITERS. 5 DETECTIVES. 4 DAYS. 3 WEAPONS. 2 MURDERS. 1 TRAIN...
The program is a who’s who of crime-writing royalty:
the debut writer (me!)
the forensic science writer
the blockbuster writer
the legal thriller writer
the literary writer
the psychological suspense writer.
But when one of us is murdered, six authors quickly turn into five detectives. Together, we should know how to solve a crime.
Or commit one.
How can you find a killer when all the suspects know how to get away with murder?
MY THOUGHTS:
"Everyone on this train is a suspect..."
"Including you?"
"Well, no."
"Why not?"
"Because I'm the narrator."
Ben Stevenson has done it again...only better! I thoroughly enjoyed the first book and sequels are notoriously hard to match the success of the first but, well, in three words - he nailed it!
IT IS BETTER THAN THE FIRST BOOK!!
How is that possible? I don't know how but it is soooo much better it's shocking! If the first one has had the TV rights sold, then this one should be snapped up because it really is better than the first. And I gave that one five stars. So how can I top that rating with this book which was soooo shockingly good?!
Ernest Cunningham is back this time hightailing it onboard the luxurious Ghan to celebrate the Australian Mystery Writer's Society fiftieth anniversary. And once again he promises to be a reliable narrator and that he couldn't be the murderer because he's the narrator. And a book in which the first person narrating the story is the murderer just breaks one of the golden rules of mystery writing. Writers are an idiosyncratic bunch.
So Ernest undertakes this journey with Juliette (readers will remember her as the owner of the resort the last book took place at) and so it begins. Six writers, five detectives, four days, three weapons, two murders (only two?) and one train...and it all comes down to a comma! Punctuation, peoples, is important. And Ernest is a stickler for the proper use of grammar, punctuation and the golden rules of detective fiction.
So the Ghan. It's a luxurious train almost a kilometre in length (google for the mile conversion) and traverses the dead red centre of Australia from Darwin to Adelaide and back again. That's its purpose. 2,797 epic kilometres (about 1860 miles) over four days...for a very hefty price tag. It's cheaper to fly to Europe than to travel the Ghan (everything in Australia is expensive but that's another story). And I love his description of flat (I can't remember the exact wording)...the endless nothingness edge of the world type of feeling. That flat.
So on the back of the success of his previous book "Everyone in my Family has Killed Someone" (yes, the author and Ernest share the same title), Ernest has been granted a six figure advance in lieu of his next blockbuster...if he could ever get past this writer's block, that is. Problem is, someone (or many someones) have to die for Ernest to write. And to top it off, on the tail of that and his first book's success, he is suffering from both imposter's syndrome and survivor's guilt.
Stevenson breaks the fourth wall of writing here, as he did with the first, in where he addresses the entire tale to the reader through Ernest Cunningham. And it so works! It feels as if the writer is speaking directly to you, even inserting side comments via parenthesis etc. He even dares us to work it out for ourselves by giving us the number the murderer's name is mentioned and that a comma will save the day. He even pauses (mid-scene) to give us a chance to lay our own thoughts and guesses on the page before the big reveal. And to be fair, he does give us all the clues throughout. Nothing is hidden and all is laid bare. But...he is a little sneakier this time a subtle change that, while it is there to note, it's hiding in plain sight. But unlike the first, I didn't quite guess the murderer, but I was very close.
And the humour. Oh my, the humour is here in spades! There were times I had to go back and re-read what I'd just read I was laughing so much! I love the wit and humour that sneaks in and peppered throughout. So thoroughy entertained by the humour alone that I didn't even notice that it was already 38% through and in Chapter 11 before someone died! That speaks to the author's ability to keep his audience entertained in lieu of the murder mystery they came here for.
My only criticism is that the title of one of the books "Life, Death and Whiskey" was purportedly written by a Scottish author and the Scottish spell "whisky" without the E. Only the Irish and Americans spell it with an E. Don't worry, readers, this is not a spoiler. This is just an observation made when reading, the spelling of which bore no significance to the mystery.
With all that this story entailed, I devoured this witty and deliciously devious mystery in a day. I was not going to bed before I turned that last page. I thoroughly enjoyed the journey (the only way I could afford a trip on the Ghan) and cannot wait for Ernest's next adventure. If I thought "Everyone in my Family has Killed Someone" was a hard act to follow, then this one is going to be even harder to top. Sequels are generally never as good as debuts, but this one doesn't just knock the first out of the water, it drowns it first!
I loved it so much that, I'm sorry, but I'm going to have to dive straight into the third book "Everyone this Christmas has a Secret". And then where will I be? Eagerly awaiting the fourth!!
A cleverly plotted, deliciously devious and witty locked room mystery taken to a whole new level. Not just a five star read...this is a ten star read! Love love LOVED it!!
And to think...it all started with a 1 star review. No danger of that here. Stevenson NAILED it! Total genius!
MEET THE AUTHOR:
Everyone In My Family Has Killed Someone, his third novel, was a huge bestseller and has so far been sold in twenty-four territories around the world. It will soon be adapted into a major HBO TV series.
Benjamin has sold out live shows from the Melbourne International Comedy Festival all the way to the Edinburgh Festival Fringe and has appeared on ABC TV, Channel 10 and The Comedy Channel.
Social Media links:
No comments:
Post a Comment